2001후1624
Korean Supreme Court Decision No. 2001 HU 1624 states the following:
"When the scope of a divisional application is broader than that of its original application (i.e. the claims of the divisional application: A+B; and the claims of the original application: a1+A+B), if "a1" is a mere addition of a well known technology and does not bring about a new effect, the divisional application and the original application are regarded as being the same, and do not meet the requirements for filing a divisional application. However, since "a1" is a process having a new effect which is not expected from the divisional application, and it is not a mere addition of a well known technology, the divisional application, which does not include "a1" as an essential constitutional element, is different from the original application."
"When the scope of a divisional application is broader than that of its original application (i.e. the claims of the divisional application: A+B; and the claims of the original application: a1+A+B), if "a1" is a mere addition of a well known technology and does not bring about a new effect, the divisional application and the original application are regarded as being the same, and do not meet the requirements for filing a divisional application. However, since "a1" is a process having a new effect which is not expected from the divisional application, and it is not a mere addition of a well known technology, the divisional application, which does not include "a1" as an essential constitutional element, is different from the original application."