2013후2613
Supreme Court Decision 2014Hu614 Decided June 9, 2016
【Registration Invalidation (Design)】* First draft
The Plaintiff petitioned with the Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board (hereinafter the "IPTAB") against the Defendant, holder of rights to the registered design as applied to an article described as "synthetic foam plank for drawing board," for adjudication to invalidate the registered design, alleging that "the registered design constitutes a design that could have been easily created by a person who has ordinary skill in the art to which the design pertains (hereinafter "ordinary designer") by applying a shape, pattern, or color, or a combination thereof, widely known in the Republic of Korea, as it is a mere expression of the pattern of granite, a natural material, as it is on to an article." The IPTAB dismissed the Plaintiff's adjudication petition on the ground that "the registered design is found to have an aesthetic value that cannot otherwise be observed in granite in its natural state, namely, originality." The Plaintiff brought a lawsuit seeking for the revocation of the adjudication.
【Main Issues and Holdings】
[1] Purport of Article 5(2) of the former Design Act
[2] In the case where: (a) Company A petitioned for adjudication on registration invalidation against B, the holder of rights to the registered design as applied to an article described as "synthetic foam plank for drawing board"; and (b) the Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board (IPTAB) rendered an adjudication dismissing Company A's petition, the case holding that the registered design constitutes a design that could have been easily created by a person who has ordinary skill in the art to which the design pertains by applying a pattern of granite, etc., which is a well-known form of natural material
【Summary of Decision】
[1] Article 5(2) of the former Design Act (amended by Design Protection Act, Act No. 7289 of Dec. 31, 2004) provides that no design shall be eligible for design registration that could have been easily created by a person who has ordinary skill in the art to which the design pertains (hereinafter "ordinary designer") by applying a
shape, pattern, or color, or a combination thereof, widely known in the Republic of Korea before an application for design registration is filed. The purport of the provision is that a design at a low level of originality could have been easily created by an ordinary designer, and hence, is ineligible for design registration. Examples of such include: (a) a design imitating or appropriating a shape, pattern, or color, or a combination thereof, that is widely known in the Republic of Korea almost as it is; (b) notwithstanding the partial transformation, in its totality a design that is merely a commercial and functional transformation without any other recognized aesthetic value; or (c) a design merely modifying, combining, or appropriating those creative techniques or expressive means commonly used in the field to which the design pertains.
[2] In the case where: (a) Company A petitioned for adjudication on registration invalidation against B, the holder of rights to the registered design as applied to an article described as "synthetic foam plank for drawing board"; and (b) the Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board (IPTAB) rendered an adjudication dismissing Company A's petition, the Court affirmed the lower court judgment deeming the registered design to constitute a design that could have been easily created by an ordinary designer by applying a pattern of granite, etc., which is a well-known form of natural material, i.e., a shape, pattern, or color, or a combination thereof, widely known in the Republic of Korea, on the following grounds: (a) the shape of the registered design as seen in front is extremely similar to granitic pattern in its natural condition, with irregular black spots unevenly interspersed across a white background; and (b) the shape of a rectangular hexahedral plank is merely one that is widely known in the Republic of Korea.
【Reference Provisions】 [1] Article 5(2) of the former Design Act (Amended into the Design Protection Act by Act No. 7289 of Dec. 31, 2004; see Article 33(2) of the current Design Protection Act) / [2] Article 5(2) of the former Design Act (Amended into the Design Protection Act by Act No. 7289 of Dec. 31, 2004; see Article 33(2) of the current Design Protection Act)
Article 33 of the Design Protection Act (Requirements for Design Registration)
(2) Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph (1), no design (excluding a design
specified in paragraph (1)) that could have been easily created by a person who has ordinary skill in the art to which the design pertains by applying any of the following methods before an application for design registration is filed, shall be eligible for design registration:
1. A design specified in paragraph (1) 1 or 2 or a combination of such designs;
2. A shape, pattern, or color, or a combination thereof, widely known in the Republic of Korea or in a foreign country.
【Reference Cases】 [1] Supreme Court Decisions 98Hu591 decided April 10, 2001 (Gong2001Sang, 1160); 2013Hu2613 decided March 10, 2016
【Plaintiff-Appellee】 Neofoam Ltd. (Patent Attorneys Kim Byeong-jin et al., Counsel for the plaintiff-appellee)
【Defendant-Appellant】 Defendant (Patent Attorneys Park Jong-gyeong et al., Counsel for the defendant-appellant)
【Judgment of the lower court】 Patent Court of Korea Decision 2014Heo447 decided April 11, 2014
【Disposition】 The appeal is dismissed. The costs of the appeal are to be borne by the Defendant.
【Reasoning】
The grounds of appeal are examined.
1. As for the ground of appeal No. 1
Examining the case in light of pertinent provisions, including Article 32 of the former Design Act (amended by Act No. 7289 of Dec. 31, 2004; hereinafter the same), and the records, it is justifiable for the lower court to have determined that the present adjudication was erroneous for having specified the form of the present registered design based on a processed drawing other than the drawings attached to the design registration application, when ascertaining the scope of protection of the present registered design as applied to an article described as "synthetic foam plank for drawing board" (design registration number omitted). In so doing, the lower court
did not err by misapprehending the legal doctrine on ascertaining the scope of protection of a registered design, contrary to what is alleged in the ground of appeal.
2. As for the ground of appeal No. 2
Article 5(2) of the former Design Act (amended by Design Protection Act, Act No. 7289 of Dec. 31, 2004) provides that no design shall be eligible for design registration that could have been easily created by a person who has ordinary skill in the art to which the design pertains (hereinafter "ordinary designer") by applying a shape, pattern, or color, or a combination thereof, widely known in the Republic of Korea before an application for design registration is filed. The purport of the provision is that a design at a low level of originality could have been easily created by an ordinary designer, and hence, is ineligible for design registration. Examples of such include: (a) a design imitating or appropriating a shape, pattern, or color, or a combination thereof, that is widely known in the Republic of Korea almost as it is; (b) notwithstanding the partial transformation, in its totality a design that is merely a commercial and functional transformation without any other recognized aesthetic value; or (c) a design merely modifying, combining, or appropriating those creative techniques or expressive means commonly used in the field to which the design pertains (see, e.g., Supreme Court Decisions 98Hu591, Apr. 10, 2001; 2013Hu2613, Mar. 10, 2016).
The lower court determined that the present registered design constitutes a design which an ordinary designer may easily create by means of the pattern of granite, etc., as a well-known form of natural material, on the following grounds: (a) the shape of the registered design as seen in front is extremely similar to granitic pattern in its natural condition, with irregular black spots unevenly interspersed across a white background; and (b) the shape of a rectangular hexahedral plank is merely one that is widely known in the Republic of Korea.
Examining the case in light of the said doctrine and the records, the lower court's such determination is justifiable. In so determining, it did not err by misapprehending the legal doctrine on determining how easy it is to create a design, contrary to what is alleged in the ground of appeal.
3. Conclusion
Therefore, the appeal is dismissed, and the costs of the appeal are to be borne by the losing party. It is so decided as per Disposition by the assent of all participating Justices on the bench.
Justices Park Sang-ok (Presiding Justice)
Lee Sang-hoon
Kim Chang-suk (Justice in charge)
Jo Hee-de
【Registration Invalidation (Design)】* First draft
The Plaintiff petitioned with the Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board (hereinafter the "IPTAB") against the Defendant, holder of rights to the registered design as applied to an article described as "synthetic foam plank for drawing board," for adjudication to invalidate the registered design, alleging that "the registered design constitutes a design that could have been easily created by a person who has ordinary skill in the art to which the design pertains (hereinafter "ordinary designer") by applying a shape, pattern, or color, or a combination thereof, widely known in the Republic of Korea, as it is a mere expression of the pattern of granite, a natural material, as it is on to an article." The IPTAB dismissed the Plaintiff's adjudication petition on the ground that "the registered design is found to have an aesthetic value that cannot otherwise be observed in granite in its natural state, namely, originality." The Plaintiff brought a lawsuit seeking for the revocation of the adjudication.
【Main Issues and Holdings】
[1] Purport of Article 5(2) of the former Design Act
[2] In the case where: (a) Company A petitioned for adjudication on registration invalidation against B, the holder of rights to the registered design as applied to an article described as "synthetic foam plank for drawing board"; and (b) the Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board (IPTAB) rendered an adjudication dismissing Company A's petition, the case holding that the registered design constitutes a design that could have been easily created by a person who has ordinary skill in the art to which the design pertains by applying a pattern of granite, etc., which is a well-known form of natural material
【Summary of Decision】
[1] Article 5(2) of the former Design Act (amended by Design Protection Act, Act No. 7289 of Dec. 31, 2004) provides that no design shall be eligible for design registration that could have been easily created by a person who has ordinary skill in the art to which the design pertains (hereinafter "ordinary designer") by applying a
shape, pattern, or color, or a combination thereof, widely known in the Republic of Korea before an application for design registration is filed. The purport of the provision is that a design at a low level of originality could have been easily created by an ordinary designer, and hence, is ineligible for design registration. Examples of such include: (a) a design imitating or appropriating a shape, pattern, or color, or a combination thereof, that is widely known in the Republic of Korea almost as it is; (b) notwithstanding the partial transformation, in its totality a design that is merely a commercial and functional transformation without any other recognized aesthetic value; or (c) a design merely modifying, combining, or appropriating those creative techniques or expressive means commonly used in the field to which the design pertains.
[2] In the case where: (a) Company A petitioned for adjudication on registration invalidation against B, the holder of rights to the registered design as applied to an article described as "synthetic foam plank for drawing board"; and (b) the Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board (IPTAB) rendered an adjudication dismissing Company A's petition, the Court affirmed the lower court judgment deeming the registered design to constitute a design that could have been easily created by an ordinary designer by applying a pattern of granite, etc., which is a well-known form of natural material, i.e., a shape, pattern, or color, or a combination thereof, widely known in the Republic of Korea, on the following grounds: (a) the shape of the registered design as seen in front is extremely similar to granitic pattern in its natural condition, with irregular black spots unevenly interspersed across a white background; and (b) the shape of a rectangular hexahedral plank is merely one that is widely known in the Republic of Korea.
【Reference Provisions】 [1] Article 5(2) of the former Design Act (Amended into the Design Protection Act by Act No. 7289 of Dec. 31, 2004; see Article 33(2) of the current Design Protection Act) / [2] Article 5(2) of the former Design Act (Amended into the Design Protection Act by Act No. 7289 of Dec. 31, 2004; see Article 33(2) of the current Design Protection Act)
Article 33 of the Design Protection Act (Requirements for Design Registration)
(2) Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph (1), no design (excluding a design
specified in paragraph (1)) that could have been easily created by a person who has ordinary skill in the art to which the design pertains by applying any of the following methods before an application for design registration is filed, shall be eligible for design registration:
1. A design specified in paragraph (1) 1 or 2 or a combination of such designs;
2. A shape, pattern, or color, or a combination thereof, widely known in the Republic of Korea or in a foreign country.
【Reference Cases】 [1] Supreme Court Decisions 98Hu591 decided April 10, 2001 (Gong2001Sang, 1160); 2013Hu2613 decided March 10, 2016
【Plaintiff-Appellee】 Neofoam Ltd. (Patent Attorneys Kim Byeong-jin et al., Counsel for the plaintiff-appellee)
【Defendant-Appellant】 Defendant (Patent Attorneys Park Jong-gyeong et al., Counsel for the defendant-appellant)
【Judgment of the lower court】 Patent Court of Korea Decision 2014Heo447 decided April 11, 2014
【Disposition】 The appeal is dismissed. The costs of the appeal are to be borne by the Defendant.
【Reasoning】
The grounds of appeal are examined.
1. As for the ground of appeal No. 1
Examining the case in light of pertinent provisions, including Article 32 of the former Design Act (amended by Act No. 7289 of Dec. 31, 2004; hereinafter the same), and the records, it is justifiable for the lower court to have determined that the present adjudication was erroneous for having specified the form of the present registered design based on a processed drawing other than the drawings attached to the design registration application, when ascertaining the scope of protection of the present registered design as applied to an article described as "synthetic foam plank for drawing board" (design registration number omitted). In so doing, the lower court
did not err by misapprehending the legal doctrine on ascertaining the scope of protection of a registered design, contrary to what is alleged in the ground of appeal.
2. As for the ground of appeal No. 2
Article 5(2) of the former Design Act (amended by Design Protection Act, Act No. 7289 of Dec. 31, 2004) provides that no design shall be eligible for design registration that could have been easily created by a person who has ordinary skill in the art to which the design pertains (hereinafter "ordinary designer") by applying a shape, pattern, or color, or a combination thereof, widely known in the Republic of Korea before an application for design registration is filed. The purport of the provision is that a design at a low level of originality could have been easily created by an ordinary designer, and hence, is ineligible for design registration. Examples of such include: (a) a design imitating or appropriating a shape, pattern, or color, or a combination thereof, that is widely known in the Republic of Korea almost as it is; (b) notwithstanding the partial transformation, in its totality a design that is merely a commercial and functional transformation without any other recognized aesthetic value; or (c) a design merely modifying, combining, or appropriating those creative techniques or expressive means commonly used in the field to which the design pertains (see, e.g., Supreme Court Decisions 98Hu591, Apr. 10, 2001; 2013Hu2613, Mar. 10, 2016).
The lower court determined that the present registered design constitutes a design which an ordinary designer may easily create by means of the pattern of granite, etc., as a well-known form of natural material, on the following grounds: (a) the shape of the registered design as seen in front is extremely similar to granitic pattern in its natural condition, with irregular black spots unevenly interspersed across a white background; and (b) the shape of a rectangular hexahedral plank is merely one that is widely known in the Republic of Korea.
Examining the case in light of the said doctrine and the records, the lower court's such determination is justifiable. In so determining, it did not err by misapprehending the legal doctrine on determining how easy it is to create a design, contrary to what is alleged in the ground of appeal.
3. Conclusion
Therefore, the appeal is dismissed, and the costs of the appeal are to be borne by the losing party. It is so decided as per Disposition by the assent of all participating Justices on the bench.
Justices Park Sang-ok (Presiding Justice)
Lee Sang-hoon
Kim Chang-suk (Justice in charge)
Jo Hee-de