경험칙
[뜻] 인간의 경험에서 얻어지는 사물의 성상, 인과관계에 대한 지식이나 법칙.
★ empirical rules 경험칙.
* It has empirically been determined that ....
* [화학팀 거절이유 통상 문구 1] Judging from the empirical rules in the chemical field, even a little change of a chemical structure may make it difficult to anticipate the effect therefrom. Thus, although the specification needs not describe every working examples for all of the compounds described in the claims, the specification should specifically disclose the representative compounds and the claims should claim the scope which is recognized as being appropriate and reasonable based on such specifically disclosed compounds.
* [화학팀 거절이유 통상 문구 2] Judging from the empirical rules in the chemical field, even a little change of a chemical structure may make it difficult to expect the effect obtained therefrom. Thus, although the specification needs not describe every working examples for all of the compounds described in the claims, the specification should specifically disclose representative compounds and the claims should claim the scope which is recognized as being appropriate and reasonable based on such specifically disclosed compounds. Thus, the above claims are too comprehensive to be supported by the specification.
* [화학팀 거절이유 통상 문구 3] In this respect, judging from the empirical rules in the chemical field, there are many cases where a reaction, which is considered as predictable [being naturally derived], actually leads to [proceeds to, brings] an unexpected result. Also, the reaction may result in an invention having properties, the effects of which are difficult to predict. Thus, although the working examples are not needed for all the compounds described in the claims, it is required to specifically describe the working examples for representative compounds. The claims should claim the scope of right of a chemical material by describing it to an appropriate and reasonable extent based on such specifically-described compounds. Therefore, the above claims including the comprehensive compounds are described too comprehensively to be supported by the detailed description. 화학분야의 경험칙상 당연히 유도될 것으로 보이는 반응이 실제로는 예상외의 반응으로 진행되는 경우가 많고, 그에 따른 효과를 예측하기 곤란한 특성을 갖는 발명이 될 수 있으므로, 특허청구범위에 기재된 모든 화합물에 대한 실시예를 필요로 하는 것은 아니지만, 대표적인 화합물에 대해서만은 구체적인 개시가 필요하며, 특허청구범위에는 그와 같이 구체적으로 개시된 물질을 중심으로 적절하고도 합리적이라고 할 수 있는 정도까지 확장하여 화학물질의 청구범위를 청구하는 것이다.