1997후2200
In this regard, the Korean Supreme Court followed by applying the doctrine of equivalents in a scope confirmation case decided on July 28, 2000 (Case No. 97 Hu 2200). The Highest Court considered the following factors to be controlling:
(1) The patented process and the accused process are built on the same technical constitution of accomplishing the same inventive purpose of producing a same product, employing an identical starting material;
(2) The reactant employed in the accused process is recognized to have substantially the same function and produce substantially the same result as those of the one employed in the patented process; and
(3) Further, the reactant of the accused process was already known in the relevant art at the time of filing the subject patent application, and the interchangeability of the reactants to give substantially the same function could be easily conceived by an ordinary person skilled in the art.
(1) The patented process and the accused process are built on the same technical constitution of accomplishing the same inventive purpose of producing a same product, employing an identical starting material;
(2) The reactant employed in the accused process is recognized to have substantially the same function and produce substantially the same result as those of the one employed in the patented process; and
(3) Further, the reactant of the accused process was already known in the relevant art at the time of filing the subject patent application, and the interchangeability of the reactants to give substantially the same function could be easily conceived by an ordinary person skilled in the art.